How We Rate and Review Devices

Meta title: Revealing the secret of Reviewing Process – How we Rate and Rank Vapes Meta description: Want to know what it takes to properly review a vaping device? Here is a look at the Vaping Daily review process, from beginning to end.

The review process for a vaping device begins the moment it lands on a reviewer’s desk. It does not stop until the review is online and available for everyone to see. Even then, we review our reviews in case there are updates or changes to the device, or if there is a recall or defect. The Vaping Daily mission is to help as many people as we can find their right vape. The only (best) way to do that is to use and review as many devices as we can.

  • Rating Process
  • Rating Process 1
  • Rating Process 2
  • Rating Process 3
  • Rating Process 4
  • Rating Process 6

Vaping Daily Score System

From its packaging to its look, from the inside to the outside, our reviewers go through everything that matters to vapers. Every device gets the scrutiny it deserves and that our readers expect from us. Different standards apply to different devices though. We label each new product into its appropriate category and take it from there.

We rate every device in four categories:

  • Appearance (25)

    Appearance
  • Performance (25)

    Performance
  • Cost (25)

    Cost
  • Quality (25)

    Quality

Each category has a twenty-five point high score. Vapes can receive a score anywhere from zero to twenty-five at each level. In the end, the total score is tallied using the result in each a category, and our reviewers assign a score out of 100.

Overall = score/100


Vaping Daily Score System #2

Every device receives a final score based on a ten-point scale in three different areas:

  • Value - Looks at whether the device is worth its price, what other costs its use and upkeep incur, and whether it provides a pleasurable vaping experience;
  • Quality - Looks at both the build quality (what materials it is made of), whether it is durable and can withstand repeated, daily use and how it performs in an area of vapor production;
  • Overall - This category combines “value” and “quality” and makes a final determination of the product’s overall rating.

For example, a device may score a six or seven in Value, which gives it a score of “good” in that category. A score can fall into any of the point groups that define a particular score:

  • 10-8 = Exceptional
  • 7-6 = Good
  • 5-3 = Average
  • 1-2 = Poor
  • Poor

    • 1
    • 2
  • Average

    • 3
    • 4
    • 5
  • Good

    • 6
    • 7
    • 8
  • Exceptional

    • 9
    • 10

The Review Process

To make the most accurate, and in-depth reviews, our reviewers first classify each new device into a type of vaping devices:

Every other product we review — e-juice, brands, vape accessories — gets reviewed as a single product in a single review. After classification, our reviewers begin from the moment they see the device in its packaging, even before opening it.

A product’s exterior packaging also has something to say, so we make a note of those kinds of things as well. Every review follows the same path as the user’s experience with the vape. We open the device, check its packing, and examine the kit’s contents.

What kind of accessories it comes with, or does not come with, is also something our reviewers keep in mind during the review process. During the review, our reviewers are also taking mental notes of any similarities it has to other devices to make a comparison between them.

This comparison is important, so people are aware of the options they have. If they don’t like the device being reviewed, they at least know about other the choices that are out there. A lot of time is spent using every device. Our reviewers take them home, use vapes in the office, and go out to socialize with every device we have ever reviewed.

We do real-world tests, but to get a real understanding of what a device can and cannot do we also push it to its limits. These tests are not recommended for anyone to do except professionals, but they give us a better understanding of the device’s qualities.


When the time comes to do the review, our writers describe in detail:

Appearance/Kit Contents — how a device looks before opening it, what’s inside the kit, its exterior build material, its aesthetic design, and ultimately how it looks and feels when handling it;

Options and features — look at what a device offers regarding customization, user input, and vaping enjoyment, as well as things it does that no other device does and whether it does them well or not;
Competition — what is the competition doing in a similar category or area that is different, the same, worse, or better than the product being reviewed;
Performance — does the device do its job, and does it do it well, no matter the material (e-juice, herbs, waxes) is the vapor of high-quality for the device’s specifications, or not;
Pros and cons — reasons to like or not like a device.

Our writers also include any personal opinions and comments they have to make about their experience with the vape. Whether they are e-liquid, dry herb or wax vaporizers, there is a perfect vaping device for everyone, maybe even more than one.

Vaping Daily wants everyone to enjoy vaping. To us, vaping is fun, and if our readers are not having fun because they still haven’t found the right vape for them yet, then we want to help them do that.